This will probably deserve the award of "Most depressing book of the year" - I know we're only in January but I'm pretty sure of myself. I read it before (because I'd seen the film with Liam Neeson) and only remembered that there was a tragic love story inside, but I didn't remember to what extent !
I didn't like the beginning, I felt it was unnecessary and too long for too little uninteresting information. When the story by itself finally started, I appreciated the writing style of the author, how she set the narrative, the description of the landscape and weather, the details on the life of people who weren't rich, how the lack of money could influence their lives. I could feel how these characters were trapped in their lives with no hope for escape. The ending... is just dreadful. For the characters. For my good spirits ! The conclusion, however, helped me understand the introduction, but I still believe it was too long.
"Most depressing book of the year", wow, not good then to read on a gloomy day, lol
ReplyDeleteI was appalled, lol !
DeleteOkay, not the Edith Wharton book to try for my classics reading. Good to know. :)
ReplyDeleteEspecially not during those depressing pandemic days ;)
DeleteHa. I had to laugh about your review. It's a dark story but I liked the trapped love situation they're in. Oh but just don't get on that sled! Wharton is a master and I hope to read more of her. Here's my review of it from 2017: https://www.thecuecard.com/books/home-fire-ethan-frome/
ReplyDeleteI'm glad I made you laugh, now I'm going to see your review ^^
DeleteMy mom used to brag about her crush on Liam. Sorry this book disappoints. I've been thinking a lot about climate lately and this book may not be number one on my list either. Hope you enjoy your week and find another great book instead.
ReplyDeleteI don't give up on the author and yes, if you're interested in climate, you need to read this (and to do so wrapped up in a nice duvet with a hot drink ;) Thanks, Trin Carl !
Delete